“We did not come here to rest”

Multiple-work among women in a national-religious community village

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.64166/4y0jwh38

Abstract

The paper will present a group of national-religious women who, along with their spouses, have been developing a community village. The paper will attempt to show that establishing a community village challenges, at least temporarily, traditional social patterns and norms. These include gender patterns, work related norms and the distinction between sacred and secular. Under these boundary-challenging circumstances it is difficult to create hierarchies, and the women feel committed to performing both traditional and non-traditional female tasks. This blurring of boundaries is particularly prominent against the backdrop of religious nationalism, which itself is based on the coupling of different spheres along with its messages to adolescent girls. These young girls, who study in Ulpanas, are educated to excel, simultaneously, in all areas of life – housework, career and religious work. This education stresses the need to combine religion and nationalism through intense activity and contribution at home, in the community and on a national level, as well as the importance of acting in all three spheres. Consequently, the women in this new and developing community village find themselves both creating and locked into the unending pressure to work and to excel in the various work contexts. It is 10 at night and I am at Ruthie’s house. When I called to schedule the interview, she said: “I am at work (she holds a senior position in an organisation located in a nearby city) in the morning and with the children (three children ages 8 months, 2 years and 4 years) in the afternoon, but after I put them to sleep at 9 I will be glad to meet.” She told me that her evening hours are mostly dedicated to activity in one of the village committees on which she serves. This activity demands the investment of about 6 hours a week spent in committee meetings, on correspondence and addressing future plans. When I inquired about her choice to combine work, children and public activity, Ruthie told me that this was not even an issue – “It is my village and I must be active for its success.” As we sit down for the interview, I am impressed by the tidiness and style of Ruthie’s small home and by her hospitality, including her homemade cookies. I ask her to tell me about life in the young and evolving village only established three years ago. Ruthie uses the word “work” repeatedly in numerous and varied contexts. She describes the work involved in establishing the village and her activity on village committees, her career work as well as parenthood – which she also refers to as work – with an emphasis on having a large family, along with nurturing her marriage and working on shaping her personal religious identity and that of the entire village. The picture that emerges from conversations with Ruthie and her female friends who established the village is one of women strongly committed to all work spheres and constantly involved with all these spheres. Their perception of work presents a renewed definition of gender boundaries, and of the tasks required of women.

References

Aharon, G. (2006). Inequality in the home: Economic dependence of married women in Israel over time. Israeli Sociology, 8(1), 87-111. [Hebrew]

Amar-Halevy, G. (2013). Male identity among graduates of the national religious education: thoughts after a research. Deot, 59, 16-20.

El-Or, T. (1998). Next Passover - Women and literacy among religious Zionists. Tel Aviv: Am Oved. [Hebrew]

El-Or, T. & Neriya, A. (2003). The Ultra-Orthodox wanderer - Time and space consumption in the Ultra-Orthodox population in Jerusalem. In E. Sivan & K. Kaplan (Eds.), The Israeli Ultra-Orthodox: Integration without assimilation (pp. 171-195). Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuhad. [Hebrew]

El-Or, T., and Aran, G. (2010). Giving birth to a settlement. In E. Hertzog, O. Abuhav, H. Goldberg &E. Marx (Eds.), Perspectives on Israeli anthropology (pp. 315-332). Detroit, Michigan: Wayne State University Press.

Feige, M. (2002). One space, two places: Gush Emunim, Peace Now and the construction of Israeli space. Jerusalem: Magnes Press. [Hebrew]

Fischer, S. (2009). Religious Zionism at the threshold of the third Millennium: Two radical religious Zionist cultures. Akdamot., 22, 9-38. [Hebrew]

Geiger, Y. (2001). The new religious Zionism. Akademot. ,11(5), 51-77. [Hebrew]

Gross, Z. (2012). The world of Zionist religious women in Israel - Between charisma and rationalism. Ramat Gan: Bar Ilan, Eliezer Stern Institute for the Study and Advancement of Religious Education, School of Education. [Hebrew]

Gross, Z. (2003). The social roles of the religious Zionist education. In A. Sagi & D. Schwartz (Eds.), A hundred years of religious Zionism III (pp. 129-186). Ramat Gan: Bar-Ilan University Press. [Hebrew]

Hartsock, N. (1983/2006). The feminist standpoint: Developing the ground for a specifically feminist historical materialism. In D. Baum et al. (Eds.), Learning feminism: A reader (pp. 195-222). Tel Aviv: Hakibutz Hameuchad Publications, Migdarim Series.

Hochschild, A.R. & Machung, A. (1989). The Second Shift. New York: Magill.

Inbari, M. (2008). Fundamentalism in crisis: The response of the Gush Emunim rabbinical authorities to the theological dilemmas raised by Israel's disengagement plan. In H. Misgav & and U. Lebel (Eds.), In the shadow of the disengagement plan: strategic dialog in crisis (pp. 285-310). Netanya: Carmel Publishing and Netanya Academic College. [Hebrew]

Israel-Cohen, Y. (2012). Between feminism and orthodox Judaism: Resistance, identity, and religious change in Israel. Leiden: Brill. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1163/9789004235311

Kahane Uli, G. & Court, D. (2013). From 'Asur, Asur, Asur' to 'the big Mutar': Religious-Zionist women's views on sex Education in Israel. International Journal of Jewish Education Research, 4, 29-67.

Kaniel, S. (2002). The religious Zionist: Toward the new era. Religious Education: The Official Journal of the Religious Education Association, 95(4), 453-473. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/0034408000950407

Kehat, H. (2008). Feminism and Judaism - From confrontation to renewal. Tel-Aviv: Broadcast University Series, Israel Ministry of Defense Publishing [Hebrew].

Keshet, S. (2011). Writing women in pioneer society: Dialectic of double consciousness in Israel. Israel, 99, 18-19 [Hebrew].

Koren, I. (2011). You are hereby renewed unto me - Gender, religion and power relations in the Jewish wedding ritual. Jerusalem: Magnes. [Hebrew]

Leon, N. (2011). Religion, class, and political action in religious Zionism in Israel. Democratic Culture, 12, 105-144. [Hebrew]

Neumann, B. (2009). Pioneering and desire in early Zionism. Tel-Aviv: Am Oved Publishers. [Hebrew]

Rapoport, T. (1999). The pedagogical construction of the traditional woman in the modern era: An ethnographic study of a 'holiness class'. Megamot, 39(4), 492-516. [Hebrew]

Rapoport, T. & Garb, Y. (1998). The experience of religious fortification: The coming of age of religious Zionist young women. Gender and Education, 10(1), 5-20. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09540259821069

Rapoport, T., Garb, Y. & Penso, A. (1995). Religious socialization and female subjectivity: Religious-Zionist adolescent girls in Israel. Sociology of Education, 68(1), 48-61. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/2112763

Razi, T. (2009). Forsaken children: The backyard of Mandate Tel-Aviv. Tel Aviv: Am Oved and Sapir Academic College. [Hebrew]

Rosenberg-Friedman, L. (2011). Revolutionaries despite themselves: Women and gender in religious Zionism in the Yishuv period. in M. Shilo & G. Katz (Eds.), Gender in Israel: New studies on gender in the Yishuv and the State (pp. 409-438). Beer-Sheva: Ben Gurion University. [Hebrew]

Rosenberg-Friedman, L. (2013). 'Traditional Female Jew' or 'New Israeli Woman': Female identity in a religious Moshav in pre-State Israel. in S. Fogel-Bijaoui & R. Sharabi (Eds.), Between the private and the public: Women in the Kibbutz and the Moshav (pp. 161-189). Ramat Efal and Jerusalem: Yad Tabenkin and Magnes Press, 2013. [Hebrew]

Ross, T. (2007). Expanding the palace of Torah: Orthodoxy and feminism. Tel Aviv: Alma and Am Oved. [Hebrew]

Schwartz, D. (2009). Religious Zionism and the Idea of the new man. Israel, 16, 143-164. [Hebrew]

Schwartz, D. & Baumel-Schwartz, J.T. (21012). Prolegomena to the study of women's status and identity in the religious Zionist movement. In Y. Fridlender, Y. Amonand & D. Schwartz (Eds.), Issues in the research of national Zionism (pp. 310-332). Ramat Gan: Bar-Ilan University Press. [Hebrew]

Shakdiel, L. (1999). Separation is a good idea but in fact why? On gender separation in religious high schools in Israel: A case study." In N. Ilan (Ed.), Tova's eye: Dialogue and debate in Israeli culture: Fiftieth anniversary Book in honor of Tova Han (pp. 90-109). Tel Aviv: Hakibbutz Hameuhad and Ne'emaney Tora V'avoda. [Hebrew]

Shakdiel, L. (2004). An army of women learning Torah: On identity construction processes in Misrashot Hesder for religious girls. In P. Kirmayer & and I. Basok (Eds.). Gadish, Adult. Education Yearbook (pp. 227-245). Ministry Of Education and Culture. [Hebrew]

Sharaby, R. (2002). Syncretism and adjustment: The meeting between a traditional community and a socialist community. Tel Aviv: Tcherikover Publishers. [Hebrew]

Sered, S.S. (1997). Women and religious change in Israel: Rebellion or revolution? Sociology of Religion, 58(1), 1-24. DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/3712103

Stadler, N. (1999). To earn a living or wait for a miracle. Ph.D thesis, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem. [Hebrew]

Stadler, N. (2002). Is profane work an obstacle to salvation: The case of Ultra-Orthodox Jews in contemporary Israel. Sociology of Religion, 63(4), 455-474 . DOI: https://doi.org/10.2307/3712302

Teitelbaum, N. (2011). Beyond the Mehitza: Women's partnership in synagogue and its significance in religious Zionist society in Israel. Master's thesis, Bar Ilan University. [Hebrew]

Tsarfaty, O. & Liran-Alper, D. (2010). Manifestations of feminist discourse in commercial family magazines in Ultra-Orthodox society. Kesher - Journal of Media and Communications History in Israel and the Jewish World, 40, 126-138. [Hebrew]

Zifroni, N. (2008). The young woman and the protest. Eretz Acheret, 44, 73.

Downloads

Published

2014-06-01

How to Cite

Cicurel, I. E. (2014). “We did not come here to rest”: Multiple-work among women in a national-religious community village. Hagar: Studies in Society and Culture, 11(2), 15-33. https://doi.org/10.64166/4y0jwh38